Report paves way for EU to renew glyphosate use

The European Food Safety Authority said on Thursday it had not found "any critical areas of concern" preventing the controversial and widely used herbicide glyphosate from being reauthorised for use in the European Union.

One of the range of Bayer (ex-Monsanto) weedkillers which contain glyphosate RoundUp. Robyn Beck / AFP

The European Union agency's long-awaited assessment report noted there were gaps in the data in some areas, and that it had "identified a high long-term risk to mammals in 12 out of 23 proposed uses of glyphosate".

But the EFSA said it only considered a concern "critical" when it affected all proposed uses of the substance, which would prevent it from being renewed.

The study, which was submitted to the European Commission and member states, will serve as a basis for the EU's upcoming decision on whether to renew the use of glyphosate in the bloc for another five years.

The current authorisation runs out on 15 December.

The full report, which is expected to be released by the end of the month, is based on some 24,000 studies, as well as responses from 90 experts from member states, the EFSA said.

Today, we publish a summary of the EU assessment and peer review of #glyphosate: no critical areas of concern for human, animal health and the environment; some data gaps.

Our conclusions have been shared with the @EU_Commission and Member States.

→ https://t.co/vuykYIQXy3 pic.twitter.com/Jgq7H4LYLf

— EFSA (@EFSA_EU) July 6, 2023

The agency said that because of a lack of data it had not finalised its risk assessment of glyphosate's impact on aquatic plants.

It also did not give advice on the risks of food consumption, "due to incomplete data about the amount of glyphosate residues in rotational crops such as carrots, lettuce and wheat".

It added that this was not expected to lead to toxicological safety levels being exceeded, "so no critical concern was identified".

Bayer welcomed the EFSA's conclusions, saying they laid the foundation for glyphosate's approval to be renewed in the EU.

'Toxic for people and the environment'

But environmental groups lashed out at the announcement, saying there was scientific evidence that glyphosate may cause cancer, poison aquatic life and can be fatal to key pollinators like bees.

"For years the evidence of glyphosate's toxicity for people and the environment has been stacking up but the European Food Safety Authority has once again decided to sweep it under the carpet," said Greenpeace EU pesticides campaigner Eva Corral.

For years the evidence of #glyphosate’s toxicity for people and the environment has been stacking up

But today the European food safety authority @EFSA_EU has once again decided to sweep it under the carpet

Our comment:https://t.co/kT9MyCxhAi

— Greenpeace EU (@GreenpeaceEU) July 6, 2023

Another campaign group, Corporate Europe Observatory, said the EFSA's advice "is a slap in the face".

"How could EFSA give glyphosate a thumbs-up based on primarily shoddy, corporate-led scientific studies?" the group said.

Glyphosate is the main ingredient in the widely used Roundup weedkiller from US agrochemical firm Monsanto, which was bought by German chemicals giant Bayer in 2018.

Bayer has since faced a wave of lawsuits in the United States over claims that glyphosate causes cancer. The firm denies such claims, but has paid out billions of dollars to settle legal disputes.

• Bayer pays $10.9 billion to settle controversial Monsanto weedkiller case

The World Health Organization's International Agency for Research on Cancer said in 2015 that glyphosate was "probably carcinogenic".

France's medical research institute INSERM said in 2021 that glyphosate has a "moderate presumed link" with the cancer non-Hodgkin lymphoma.

Despite that, the European Chemicals Agency said last year the available evidence did not justify classifying the substance as a carcinogen.

Health risks vs food production

Policymakers are under pressure to reduce the use of synthetic pesticides, insecticides and fertilisers over health concerns, while safeguarding farmer welfare and food production.

In southern France, on Thursday, French cherry farmers dumped a tonne of rotting fruit in front of a government building to protest against an insecticide ban that has left them vulnerable to fruit flies.

The EU implemented a bloc-wide ban in 2020 on the insecticide dimethoate over health risks posed to farmers and consumers.

The chemical had previously been used to treat fruit fly on a range of crops.

(with AFP)